Pia Toscano On Possible Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler Replacements

PiaFan1
PiaFan1's picture
Offline
Extreme PiaFan
Joined: 04/03/2011

Great Idea about Adam Lambert becouse I think he would be a very smart impartial Judge and I also happen to be a Big Fan. But I don't Love any Artist like I LOVE Pia, she's the Best.

LanceRW
LanceRW's picture
Offline
Major PiaFan
Joined: 03/07/2011

I believe Adam Lambert would make a great Judge. They need to get Judges who will be totally impartial. Last year's Judging was a train wreck being there was little Judging and instead way too much Cheerleading.  One option I have heard about is Charlie Sheen. He would make the Judging even more of a joke. Let's have Judges that will take their duties seriously.

UgotaLuvPia
UgotaLuvPia's picture
Offline
Major PiaFan
Joined: 03/15/2011

I agree that Adam Lambert would make a great judge.  He would keep things interesting too.

olemanbob
olemanbob's picture
Offline
Major PiaFan
Joined: 04/09/2011

Until American Idol changes the voting system, it don't matter who the judges will be.For example with DWTS you have a limit on how many votes you can cast, as with AI it's a JOKE!

GaryOC
GaryOC's picture
Offline
Extreme PiaFan
Joined: 03/24/2011

olemanbob wrote:

Until American Idol changes the voting system, it don't matter who the judges will be.For example with DWTS you have a limit on how many votes you can cast, as with AI it's a JOKE!

Amen, Bob!

rocky95
rocky95's picture
Offline
Extreme Piafan
Joined: 07/20/2011

Harvey Mason Jr, Rob Thomas and Aretha Franklin.

Tony4PiaToscano
Tony4PiaToscano's picture
Offline
Super PiaFan
Joined: 02/05/2012

 Loved the interview Pia!!! You are so beautiful and an angel. I think Katy Perry and Adam Lambert would be great. You would be even better.

Love you P

rocky95
rocky95's picture
Offline
Extreme Piafan
Joined: 07/20/2011

Didn't Katy Perry already say no?  What about Miley Cyrus?   Mariah, Miley Cyrus and Rodney Jerkins?

 

LanceRW
LanceRW's picture
Offline
Major PiaFan
Joined: 03/07/2011

GaryOC wrote:

olemanbob wrote:

Until American Idol changes the voting system, it don't matter who the judges will be.For example with DWTS you have a limit on how many votes you can cast, as with AI it's a JOKE!

Amen, Bob!

Yes indeed olemanbob, you are so right. I think most of the Sweet P's agree with you there. However the question is who will make a good judge? I can see where just about any former Idol contestant would do a good job. (btw: not our Pia, she has a lot of singing to do yet)